Question 3 - Part b
In this 20-minute lesson, you'll learn how to critically appraise key audit matters disclosed in an auditor's report—a vital skill for exam success. Using a worked example from Branson Co's audit report, you'll discover what makes a key audit matter appropriate, what shouldn't be included, and what's missing entirely.
This lesson is part of a paid course
Buy the course to unlock every video lesson and the AI Tutor, plus mock exams with feedback on CIMA courses.
Already bought? Sign in
Ask the AI tutor anything about this lesson
It knows every lesson in the course — explanations, clarifications, practice questions.
In this lesson
- 0:00 Part B: Critically appraising key audit matters
- 0:33 Understanding the task and marking approach
- 1:46 Scenario overview: Branson Co going concern issues
- 3:29 Identifying what belongs in key audit matters
- 4:20 Analysis of going concern paragraph problems
- 8:16 Analysis of contract win paragraph issues
- 11:15 Structuring your answer: going concern section
- 14:35 Structuring your answer: contract win section
- 17:01 Demonstrating professional judgement and acumen
About this lesson
You'll develop the analytical eye needed to spot professional issues, commercial risks, and disclosure gaps that earn you marks in the exam. This session walks you through a realistic eight-mark question that requires you to evaluate both the going concern disclosure and a contract win announcement in the auditor's report. You'll learn why certain statements—like expressing confidence in parent company support or using congratulatory language—create liability risks for the audit firm and breach professional standards. The lesson shows you how to distinguish between what belongs in the material uncertainty relating to going concern paragraph versus what should appear in key audit matters, and why referring users to audited financial statement notes is fundamentally different from directing them to unaudited operating reviews. By working through this example, you'll understand the commercial and professional judgment required to score well on case study questions. You'll see how identifying issues like vague descriptions, inappropriate opinions, and unprofessional tone doesn't just earn you marks—it demonstrates the commercial acumen that examiners reward. This approach applies directly to AA papers and helps you build confidence in evaluating real audit reporting scenarios.
Duration: 20m
Transcript
Every lesson comes with a full searchable transcript - included with the course.
Get the Advanced Audit and Assurance course
All 177 video lessons, an AI Tutor in every lesson and lifetime access.
Already bought? Sign in